In 2003, the Space Shuttle Columbia burned up on re-entry into the Earth’s atmosphere because of a hole in its wing. All seven crew members died in the accident.
Engineers discovered the problem while the shuttle was still in orbit and quickly put together assessments of the damage. They presented their assessments using PowerPoint slides.
Like many organizations and businesses, NASA was extremely reliant upon slide presentations. In this case, it contributed to a fatal error, according to Yale professor emeritus Edward Tufte.
As a data analysis consultant for NASA following the Columbia accident, Tufte analyzed the reports and research produced during those days the shuttle was in orbit and determined that the way the information was presented in the slides minimized the threats to the shuttle. Tufte concluded that written technical reports were the best way to present critical information like that related to the Columbia mission.
The Columbia shuttle case is an extreme instance of how our reliance upon slide software like PowerPoint can actually hinder a presentation instead of helping it, but there is still a lesson to be learned. As Tufte relates in a column in Wired magazine, PowerPoint is meant to compliment a presentation, not be the presentation.










